When planning an outdoor lighting project, selecting the right pole type is crucial to ensuring the durability, performance, and longevity of your system. Two primary options are bolt-down steel poles and direct burial composite poles, each offers specific advantages based on environmental conditions, installation requirements, and long-term maintenance needs. Understanding these differences and knowing how to install a light pole will help you make the most suitable choice for your project.
Here is an examination of the key differences between these two types of poles, focusing on installation methods, material characteristics, and real-world applications, and providing a comparison of their advantages and drawbacks.
Key Takeaways
-
- Installation and Stability: Bolt-down steel poles provide superior stability but require a concrete foundation, while direct burial composite poles are quicker and cheaper to install.
- Material Suitability: Steel poles are strong and ideal for heavy-duty use, but need anti-corrosion treatments in coastal areas. Composite poles resist corrosion naturally, making them better for coastal environments.
- Maintenance and Costs: Bolt-down steel poles are easier to maintain and replace, while composite poles require less upkeep but are harder to replace once buried.
Light Pole Installation Methods: Bolt Down vs. Direct Burial Poles
The installation process has a significant impact on the stability and cost of your project. Understanding how each method works will help you determine the best solution for your lighting needs.
Bolt Down Poles
Bolt-down poles are mounted onto a pre-poured concrete foundation with embedded anchor bolts. The pole is then secured to the base with washers and nuts, creating a firm, long-lasting connection.
Typical Applications:
- Parking lots
- Sports fields
- Urban streets
- Industrial areas
These poles are ideal in high-traffic or wind-exposed locations where structural stability is essential.
Advantages:
- Superior Stability: The concrete foundation offers exceptional stability, even in harsh weather conditions.
- Easy Replacement: If the pole needs replacing, the foundation stays intact, allowing the new pole to be easily mounted onto the existing base.
- Supports Heavier Fixtures: Bolt down poles are ideal for larger, heavier lighting fixtures, such as those used in sports facilities.
Drawbacks:
- Higher Installation Costs: The concrete foundation adds material and labor costs, extending project timelines due to the curing period.
- Complex Installation: Installation requires more planning, heavy equipment, and additional time compared to direct burial methods.
Direct Burial Poles
Direct burial poles are installed by placing the pole base directly into a pre-dug hole, then backfilling the hole with compacted soil, gravel, or concrete for stabilization. No concrete foundation is required.
Typical Applications:
- Parks and recreational areas
- Rural roads and pathways
- Coastal and saltwater environments
These poles are preferred for areas where corrosion resistance and quick, cost-effective installation are essential.
Advantages:
- Faster Installation: Without the need for a concrete foundation, the installation process is quicker and less labor-intensive.
- Lower Costs: Fewer materials are required, which leads to significant savings in both labor and installation.
- Corrosion Resistance: Composite direct burial poles resist corrosion, making them ideal for coastal and high-moisture environments.
Drawbacks:
- Harder to Replace: Once installed, replacing direct burial poles can be costly and labor-intensive since they require excavation.
- Reduced Stability: In softer soils or regions prone to ground shifts, direct burial poles may not offer the same stability as those mounted on concrete foundations.
Material Types: Steel vs. Composite Light Poles
The choice of material for your lighting poles significantly influences their performance, longevity, and suitability for different environments. Each material type, steel and composite has unique properties that make it ideal for certain applications, and understanding these characteristics will help ensure you choose the best option for your lighting project.
Steel Poles
Ideal For:
- Urban and industrial areas
- High-wind and high-traffic zones
- Heavy-duty applications (e.g., large-scale lighting)
Advantages:
- High Strength: Steel poles offer superior strength, making them ideal for supporting large fixtures and withstanding high winds.
- Customizability: Steel poles can be manufactured to specific heights and strengths, offering flexibility in design.
- Long Lifespan: With the right coatings (e.g., galvanization), steel poles can last for decades.
Drawbacks:
- Corrosion Risk: Steel is prone to rust in coastal areas unless protected with anti-corrosive coatings, which can increase costs.
- Example: In Santa Monica, steel poles required special coatings to resist saltwater corrosion.
- Heavier and More Expensive to Install: The weight of steel poles necessitates more labor, equipment, and cost to transport and install.
Composite Poles
Ideal For:
- Coastal and corrosive environments
- Parks and recreational areas
- Solar lighting projects
Advantages:
- Corrosion Resistance: Composite poles are naturally resistant to rust, making them ideal for coastal or high-moisture locations.
- Example: In Florida Keys, composite poles were chosen for their ability to resist saltwater corrosion.
- Lightweight: These poles are much lighter than steel, reducing labor and transport costs.
- Low Maintenance: Unlike steel, composite poles do not need coatings or frequent maintenance, making them easier to care for in the long term.
Drawbacks:
- Limited Strength: Composite poles do not offer the same load-bearing capacity as steel, making them unsuitable for heavy fixtures or high-wind areas.
- Less Stability in Soft Soils: Composite poles may require additional engineering in softer or shifting soils to ensure they remain securely anchored.
Access Fixtures composite poles are made from an advanced composite material with integrated UV protection that combines an ultra-strong polyurethane resin and E-glass fiber rovings. The poles can also be pre-drilled and pre-assembled.
Considering Sand, Saltwater, and Structural Engineering Before Installing
When installing light poles, environmental factors such as soil type, salt exposure, and wind speeds play a crucial role in determining the right pole type and installation method. Proper planning in these conditions can prevent structural issues and reduce long-term maintenance.
Sandy Environments
In areas like Santa Monica, sandy soil requires deeper burial for direct burial poles to ensure stability. Poles should be buried at a depth of 10% of the pole’s height plus 3 feet. For example, a 30-foot pole should be buried at least 6 feet deep to prevent shifting. Additionally, using gravel or concrete backfill helps secure the pole in loose sand, which is essential for areas prone to high winds.
Coastal and Saltwater Areas
In coastal regions such as the Florida Keys, composite poles are often favored due to their natural resistance to corrosion. Unlike steel, composite poles don’t require costly anti-corrosion coatings or frequent maintenance. If using steel poles, they must be treated with corrosion-resistant coatings like galvanization to withstand salt exposure, but these treatments will still need periodic maintenance over time.
Wind Load Considerations
High-wind areas, common in both sandy and coastal environments, require poles with higher wind load capacity. Bolt down steel poles offer superior stability in such conditions due to their secure foundation and structural strength. Direct burial poles in high-wind zones need deeper burial and, in some cases, extra anchoring to ensure they remain secure.
Structural Engineering
For challenging environments, structural engineering is essential to ensure proper installation. Engineers can assess:
- Pole depth and backfill requirements based on soil conditions and wind loads.
- Load-bearing capacity to ensure poles can support fixtures in high-wind or high-traffic areas.
- Corrosion protection strategies to determine if steel poles with coatings or composite poles are the better option.
By accounting for these factors, you can ensure a stable, long-lasting installation that minimizes risks and maintenance costs over time.
Comparison Table: Bolt Down Steel Poles vs. Direct Burial Composite Poles
| Pole Type | Bolt Down Steel Poles | Direct Burial Composite Poles |
|---|---|---|
| Installation Method | Requires concrete foundation and anchor bolts | Buried directly into the ground |
| Installation Cost | Higher due to foundation and labor costs | Lower, no need for a concrete foundation |
| Maintenance | Easy to replace with minimal disruption | Harder and costlier to replace once buried |
| Corrosion Resistance | Requires special coatings in coastal areas | Naturally corrosion-resistant |
| Stability | High stability for large fixtures | Adequate but may shift in soft soils |
| Ideal Environment | Urban, industrial, high-traffic areas | Coastal, rural, and high-moisture environments |
| Weight | Heavy, requires more labor and equipment | Lightweight, easier to transport |
| Lifespan | Long-lasting with regular maintenance | Long-lasting with minimal maintenance |
Conclusion
Choosing between bolt down steel poles and direct burial composite poles ultimately depends on your project’s specific needs, environmental conditions, and long-term maintenance considerations.
- Bolt down steel poles are the ideal choice for urban, industrial, or high-traffic environments where stability and the ability to support heavy fixtures are crucial. While they require higher upfront installation costs due to the concrete foundation, their durability and ease of replacement make them a reliable, long-term solution.
- Direct burial composite poles, on the other hand, are best suited for coastal or rural environments where corrosion resistance and quick installation are key. They offer a cost-effective, low-maintenance alternative, especially in areas exposed to saltwater or moisture, though they may lack the structural strength needed for larger fixtures or high-wind zones.
By carefully assessing factors like soil type, wind load, and corrosion risks, and possibly consulting with a structural engineer, you can make an informed decision that ensures your outdoor lighting system performs reliably for years to come. For expert advice or tailored recommendations, reach out to our lighting specialists—we’re here to help guide you to the best solution for your project’s unique requirements.
Bolt Down Steel vs. Direct Burial Composite Poles Frequently Asked Questions
You have questions about choosing the right light pole for you project. We have answers. If you have a question that isn’t answered below, contact an Access Fixtures lighting specialist at (800) 468-9925 or click here.
What are the key steps involved in light pole installation?
Light pole installation involves selecting the appropriate pole type (bolt down or direct burial), preparing the foundation or hole, securing the pole with anchor bolts or soil backfill, wiring the electrical components through conduits, and mounting the light fixture.
What is the difference between bolt down and direct burial pole installation?
Bolt down poles require a concrete foundation with embedded anchor bolts for stability, while direct burial poles are installed directly into the ground, secured with compacted soil or gravel. Bolt down poles provide superior stability, while direct burial poles offer quicker, more cost-effective installation but are harder to replace.
How do you run wiring for street lights or lamp poles?
Wiring for street lights or lamp poles typically runs through conduit installed underground. The conduit protects the wiring from environmental factors and connects to a junction box or control panel to power the light.
Why is conduit important in light pole installation?
Conduit protects the wiring from environmental damage such as moisture or soil movement. It also makes future repairs and maintenance easier by providing a clear pathway for wiring.
What materials are best for light pole installation in coastal areas?
Composite poles and aluminum poles are excellent for coastal environments due to their natural resistance to corrosion. Steel poles can be used, but they require anti-corrosive coatings such as galvanization to withstand saltwater exposure.
How do you install wiring in solar light poles?
Solar light poles do not require traditional underground wiring since they are powered by solar panels. However, they still need internal wiring between the solar panel, battery, and light fixture, often routed through a conduit within the pole.
What are anchor bolts and why are they used in pole installation?
Anchor bolts are embedded in a concrete foundation and used to secure bolt down poles in place. They provide stability and are essential for supporting heavy light fixtures, especially in high-wind areas.
Is aluminum a good choice for street light poles?
Yes, aluminum is an excellent material for street light poles in environments where corrosion resistance and lightweight installation are important. Aluminum poles are commonly used in urban and coastal settings for their durability and ease of maintenance.
What is the best pole type for solar light installation?
Composite poles are ideal for solar light installation, as they resist corrosion and do not require extensive underground wiring. Their lightweight nature also makes them easier to install in remote areas.
How do you replace a direct burial light pole?
Replacing a direct burial light pole involves excavating the pole from the ground, removing the old pole, and installing a new one. This process is more labor-intensive than replacing a bolt down pole, which only requires unbolting and switching out the fixture.
What is the importance of the anchor base in lamp pole installation?
The anchor base is crucial for providing stability to a lamp pole. During installation, the anchor base is bolted to a concrete foundation, ensuring the pole remains securely in place, especially in high-traffic or high-wind areas. The base also helps distribute the weight of the pole and fixtures evenly.
What are the standard installation steps for setting up a lamp post?
The typical installation steps for a lamp post include preparing the foundation, setting the anchor bolts, allowing for the appropriate bolt projection, securing the anchor base, and finally mounting the lamp post itself. Proper alignment of the anchor bolts and ensuring correct bolt projection are critical for stability.
How do you measure bolt projection for a light pole base installation?
Bolt projection refers to the distance the anchor bolts extend above the foundation, which is essential for securing the light pole. Standard bolt projection is usually around 3 to 4 inches above the concrete surface, but this can vary based on the specific lamp pole design and the thickness of the base plate.
What is the role of a bracket in light pole installations?
A bracket is used to mount light fixtures to the pole, providing support and positioning for the lights. Brackets are often designed to extend the lights away from the pole, optimizing the coverage area. In some cases, multiple brackets may be used to mount several lights on a single pole.
How do you determine the bolt circle for an anchor base installation?
The bolt circle is the diameter of the circle formed by the anchor bolts around the base of the pole. It’s crucial to match the bolt circle size with the design of the anchor base to ensure a secure fit. Bolt circles are typically measured in inches and must align perfectly with the lamp post base for proper installation.